Now showing · Genius WAIT! ×0
Movies, Books and MoreThe Spy Special · Price: one cutting chai
Filmi GibberishThe critic who did not pay for the ticket
Review · Hindi · 2018Genius

Nawaz Was Here(Voice Only)

Genius: Why? A JEE topper, a magic phone, a bomb with a javelin, and Nawazuddin, mostly heard and rarely seen.

A comic-book film set at night: a lean, stubbled actor at a microphone shrugs at the viewer and asks Why?, while the camera crew, boom mic, spotlights, wind machine and director in his chair all turn towards a skinny young hero flexing on a pedestal in a blaze of confetti, his phone in hand.

CoverEvery camera on the set, pointed at the wrong man.

Fence sitters, please step down

If you are still sitting on the fence in the nepotism debate, Genius will give you a gentle push, straight onto the #NoToNepotism side.

Nawazuddin Siddiqui is the find of Hindi cinema this decade. His dialogue delivery alone, with that unhurried, almost lazy poise, is worth the price of a ticket. So imagine my horror when, in the middle of one of his lines, the camera wanders off and settles on another actor’s face. We hear Nawaz; we watch someone else. Pure sacrilege! At that moment you don’t need Google. You simply know that the young man on screen is the son of the producer or the director. (Director, as it turns out.)

The only good thing about my Genius experience was that I didn’t pay for the ticket.

Reel 1

The hero who is everything

Nawazuddin is so underused that his role might as well be billed as a guest appearance. The “hero,” on the other hand, is determined to be everything.

First, he wants to be Sunny Deol, the man who can down a dozen goons with sheer power. Fair enough; his father did direct Gadar. The trouble is that every muscle in his body put together might weigh less than one dhai kilo ka haath, and that turns every fight sequence into comedy.

He is also super smart, so of course he is the JEE topper. Yet this genius picks IIT Roorkee. Someone forgot to tell him where Roorkee sits in the pecking order: so far down that Powai, Delhi, Kanpur, Kharagpur and Chennai barely count it as an IIT. (Roorkee alumni, please address your hate mail to the screenwriter.)

Reel 2

The phone that could

The real star of the film is his smartphone. It controls everything: traffic lights, magical lights rising out of the grass, doors, contact lenses (wirelessly, naturally), bank servers, and other people’s email accounts.

Comic panel: on a rainy night street a skinny hero in sunglasses raises a glowing phone; beams turn the traffic lights green, swing open a bank vault, unlock an email envelope and reach a floating contact lens. In a jagged inset, a moustached man in a vest stares in panic at his own phone: 1 new mail, no unread messages.
Panel IHis phone runs the city. Mine can’t find one email.

Meanwhile, my own smartphone, after the latest iOS update, tells me I have “1 new mail.” I open the mail app. There are no unread messages.

Reel 3

Wait!

To call the plot disjointed would be generous. Here is just one thread, untangled for your safety. Press the big red button whenever you are ready for the next twist. Keep an eye on the hero’s status board, and on the logic meter.

The Plot-Twist Machine

Twist 1 of 10
Legs
Limp + stick
Job
“Disabled” spy
Chasing
Nobody yet
The bomb
Not yet
Logic100%
  1. Act 1

    Early on, the hero is injured so badly that he lies in a coma for months. He recovers, but with a limp, a walking stick and constant pain. In a meeting, he is mocked as “disabled” and unfit to be a secret agent.

  2. WAIT!
    #1

    Later, he has to chase a culprit. But how can a man with a limp run? Easy: a high-tech implant mysteriously snaps onto his legs, and off he goes, no limp, no pain.

  3. WAIT!
    #2

    He wasn’t chasing a culprit after all. He was chasing a car flying the Indian flag upside down, and he stops it to set the flag right.

  4. WAIT!
    #3

    A few scenes later, the man in that car turns out to be the culprit after all.

  5. WAIT!
    #4

    Forget the implant. The truth is that the limp was an act, a trap for the bad guys.

  6. WAIT!
    #5

    It wasn’t a trap. It was an exit strategy, so he could quit the spy business and go back to his lady love.

  7. WAIT!
    #6

    He is a true patriot, so despite his exit strategy he goes back to finish the job.

  8. WAIT!
    #7

    Forced to choose between chasing the villain and saving his lady love, he saves his lady love.

  9. WAIT!
    #8

    The bomb strapped to his lady love is a fake. The real bomb is in the temple.

  10. WAIT!
    #9

    No worries, he also happens to be an Olympic-standard javelin thrower, so he can pick up the bomb and hurl it miles out to sea.

  11. WAIT!
    #10

    Oh, sorry, there is no sea. There is a river, and there are people on the other side, so the bomb…

Exhausted? Me too.Logic left the building at Wait #10.

Comic panel at sunset by a river temple: the hero, with a glowing knee brace, throws a cartoon bomb along a looping dashed path dotted with WAIT! signs, while villagers wave from the far bank. A car with an upside-down flag, a dropped walking stick and the lady love walking away fill the middle; an old officer leans on a jeep, smirking and dreaming of his own action poster, and a lean actor sits bored with a glass of chai.
Panel IIThe flight path of the bomb, and of the plot.
Reel 4

Same song, now in her voice

The absurdity doesn’t stop at the plot; it extends to everything. There’s a Himesh Reshammiya composition sung by a male voice, part of the hero’s dream sequence. Then comes a good five minutes of serious scenes. And then the very same song plays again, now in a female voice, presumably as part of the lady love’s dream. Same song. Same full length. Every single second of it.

Side AHis dream
Full length
Side BHer dream (same song)
Also full length

No fast-forward button was provided.

Reel 5

Tech support

Besides the phone, the gadgets in this film are astonishingly advanced. There’s a bomb-detection radar that can sniff out explosives within a radius of a couple of miles, yet it is fooled by cadmium paint on children’s toys.

The secret meeting room has hi-tech glass doors with fingerprint sensors built in, so you have to press your palm to the glass to get in. The glass, however, is perfectly transparent. Anyone standing outside can see the top-secret meeting, and hear every word of it too.

Reel 6

The screen-time pie

The lady love is presumably there as eye candy, yet we hardly see her, because whenever she gets one of her rare lines, you guessed it: the camera is busy with our hero.

The character seems to have been imagined as a cross between Rambo, Sherlock, Deol and Shah Rukh, with twenty percent of the reel devoted to close-ups in each avatar. That’s eighty percent gone. Of the remaining twenty, fifteen go to the technology, three to the lady love, and the last two to Nawazuddin.

Who got the screen? Our critic’s estimate, give or take a close-up

Pie chart of screen time: four hero close-up avatars at 20 percent each, technology 15 percent, the lady love 3 percent, Nawazuddin 2 percent. Rambo close-ups: 20% Sherlock close-ups: 20% Deol close-ups: 20% Shah Rukh close-ups: 20% Technology: 15% The lady love: 3% Nawazuddin: 2% 20% 20% 20% 20% 15% Nawaz is here! (2%) mostly his voice lady love (3%)
Share of the reel
SliceShareMostly
Rambo close-ups20%brooding, bare-chested, at nothing in particular
Sherlock close-ups20%squinting at clues the phone already solved
Deol close-ups20%dhai kilo ka haath, minus about two kilos
Shah Rukh close-ups20%arms wide open, lady love out of frame
Technology15%the phone, the radar, the see-through secret door
The lady love3%the back of her head
Nawazuddin2%his voice, over somebody else’s face
Total100%

Tap a slice. Try finding Nawaz without the magnifying glass.

Reel 7

Mithun’s smirk

Oh yes, Mithun Chakraborty is in the film too. At the end, he wears a little smirk, and I’m sure I know what he was thinking:

A hand-painted 1980s-style Bollywood action poster: a young hero in an olive shirt and fingerless gloves draws a gleaming blade across the frame, surrounded by a villain with a pistol, a man in a trench coat and hat, a heroine, a brooding young face and a rough-looking henchman, with a hilltop fort, a helicopter and a speeding jeep, and the word GENIUS in tall letters.
Panel IIIWhat Mithun saw when he closed his eyes: Genius, repainted the 1988 way.

The Breakdown

Critic’s report card
Genius (2018)
  • Story70%

    The chance it changes in the next scene.

  • Just Like That70%

    Scenes that happen just like that, for no reason at all.

  • Nawazuddin80%

    His lines delivered while the camera looks at someone else.

The End. Or, wait…

— Vinaay Patil, who did not pay for the ticket

Where to Watch

If you must. We did warn you. Keep your ears on Nawaz.

Showing options for

Looking up streaming platforms…

Availability data from JustWatch via TMDB. Platforms change their line-ups often, so check before you settle in.

Filed Under